Pick:
Would you rather organize the forks in your utensil drawer by pattern and preference, or use one to enjoy some amazing lasagna?
Should each of your spoons have its own name and serial number, or would you just use one with a big bowl of ice cream?
Some knives are serrated, some not. You could draw up a compare and contrast chart on their usefulness, or just pick the right one and enjoy that steak.
These choices sound silly, because they are. Most would rather skip the culinary busy work, and just chow down.
While an exaggeration of what happens with the word religion, there is a parallel.
A religion is a system of belief and practice that elevates one beyond the ordinary, focusing on the spiritual instead of only the physical, almost always involving a deity.
Some faiths seem to concentrate on repeating ritual, on rote obedience practices that can be checked off on your spiritual clipboard. These can be seen as efforts to earn favor/salvation. This Works Theology gives people a feeling that they are on the right track towards an ultimate goal.
The danger is that this can lead people into just going through the motions, a habit that makes them feel worthy. It can also convince them that they don’t need to make more fundamental and significant changes in their life.
Others feel these practices are a distraction. They would rather devote their time and energy to efforts to improve themselves and others, concentrating on the most important parts of their faith.
Still others see these rituals as proof that all faiths are a waste of time. They equate them with religion as a whole, and reject any notion that any faith has value.
Jesus understood that. The religious leadership of his day were experts at majoring in minors. It’s easier to do some small thing that you can check off your list than it is to change your heart. He would have to remind them what God said through the prophet Hosea “I desire mercy, not sacrifice.” (Hosea 6:6, Matthew 9:13, Matthew 12:7)
Other times he would call them out for prioritizing the wrong things.
“Woe to you Pharisees, because you give God a tenth of your mint, rue and all other kinds of garden herbs, but you neglect justice and the love of God. You should have practiced the latter without leaving the former undone.” Luke 11:42
Jesus wasn’t a fan of rote ritual either. He would agree with those who felt that some have become sidetracked by religious busyness.
Although God had instituted some practices in the Old Testament, the leaders substituted devotion to him with devotion to rules, misunderstanding their intent.
Unfortunately, some overreact and throw the proverbial baby out with the bathwater. Because then they don’t agree with rote ritual, they walk away from it all. This might also happen when they equate faith with “Organized Religion” or denominational structures.
They may have had some bad experience, and thus reject all faith. These are the same people who bought some fruit that spoiled, yet kept shopping for groceries. Or the people who had a misdiagnosis, but continue to see doctors. Or didn’t like the service at one restaurant, but didn’t stop eating out.
Others want to avoid expectations, and label themselves as “Spiritual not Religious.” (See https://davesoucie.wordpress.com/2019/05/04/spiritual-but-not-religious/ ) This is a Postmodern excuse at avoiding responsibility and accountability.
I understand the reluctance to avoid the word religion. But it seems an overreaction to less useful practices. It’s not God’s fault the word was ruined. Some of us are to blame.
There is an old saying that tries to distinguish between Christianity and other faiths. “Religion is man’s search for God. Christianity is God’s search for man.”
This is one of the ways that Christianity could be seen as different. Yet Christians have also been sidetracked by potentially mindless ritual.
It’s not in my power to salvage the word religion. I understand with and agree that some actions done within religions aren’t really helping anyone.
Yet to malign the word runs the risk of slandering all faith. When that happens, we all suffer, including God.
——————
Dave Soucie lives, serves and writes in Indianapolis.
Copyright © 2024 by Dave Soucie. All rights reserved [but permission is granted for non-commercial use only, with proper citation and by informing the author].